British politics has reached its Yaffle moment


Wednesday 11 March 2009

Close Window


Labour risks being seduced by the old idea that centralised power is best. That's the wrong lesson to learn from the credit crunch

By Philip Collins

On February 12, 1974, a fortnight before Labour won the most seats in a hung Parliament, a new television series began. One of its stars was a brilliant professor, a thinker who anticipated the lines that will come to divide British politics.

Every episode began with a broken but once-loved object being brought into a shop for repair. The professor did his magic and the repaired item was put in the shop window in the hope that the owner would pass by and claim it. Professor Augustus Barclay Yaffle, the brains of the operation run by Bagpuss, dear Bagpuss, Old Fat Furry Catpuss, was the creation of the presiding genius of children's programming, Oliver Postgate. And Yaffle wasn't just a carved book end in the shape of a woodpecker, though he was certainly that as well. Yaffle was based directly on Oliver Postgate's humourless but brilliant uncle, G.D.H.Cole, the Chichele Professor of Social and Political Theory at Oxford and father of Guild Socialism.

Most of Cole's ideas have not worn well but on one big issue he was right and well ahead of his time. Cole said that the most important divide in politics was between centralisers and federalisers, between those who think that power should be concentrated against those who think power is better dispersed.

This argument goes on in all three parties. Both tendencies are present in the Government - market reforms in health, a big stick at the Home Office. But a decade in power has brought diminishing returns for public service command and control.


[top]